House (17 All Stars)

Paul Amador
Scott Bedke
Megan Blanksma
Matthew Bundy
Greg Chaney
Marco Erickson
Marc Gibbs
Linda Wright Hartgen
Clark Kauffman*
Laurie Lickley*
Dustin Manwaring
Gary Marshall
Lori McCann
Scott Syme
Caroline Troy
Jon O. Weber
Rick Youngblood 

Senate (23 All Stars)

Jeff Agenbroad
Kelly Anthon*
Robert Blair
Van Burtenshaw
Kevin Cook
Carl Crabtree
Lori Den Hartog
Scott Grow
Jim Guthrie*
Mark Harris*
Lee Heider
Todd Lakey
Abby Lee*
Dave Lent
Patti Anne Lodge*
Fred Martin
Jim Patrick*
Jim Rice
Doug Ricks
Mary Souza*
Julie Van Orden*
Chuck Winder
Jim Woodward 
​Food Producers of Idaho established the Ag All-Star Award for the 2000 Legislature.
* Received award every year eligible.
Indicates first time recipient.